Archived from the Transloadit support forum. Originally posted on September 12, 2011; details may be outdated, see our docs for current behavior. Original thread
I just tried to upload a couple of FLV files on your demo page that failed. The files are encoded with:
- Screen Video Codec V2 - Speex audio
Do you support this combination? I can provide a sample if you’d like.
Any updates on this? I looked into the exact codec and it seems to be a fairly widespread codec - the fourcc code is: FSV2 (Flash Screen Video version 2)
I’m not sure if FFMPEG supports it, but I hope so.
I looked at the ffmpeg source and it seems it’s not a problem if the speex header is missing. I am not really sure though. Kevin, do you know more about this?
The real error might be this one here at the bottom:
[buffer @ 0x1b31550] Invalid pixel format string ‘-1’ Error opening filters!
I also tried to encode this into several formats with several codecs, but the error persists. It seems ffmpeg can’t analyze the meta data properly.
Did you try to upload the video to youtube yet? If so, did it work? AFAIK they also use ffmpeg.
Well, I did try uploading the FLV files to Youtube and they failed. So, it appears FFMPEG does not support the Adobce Screen codec (svc2). Do you know if that is the case? I would assume it is a relatively known/used codec.
I did upload a file with the Screen Video 1 codec, and it worked. But, the quality of that codec is very poor. I’d prefer to encode using Screen Video 2 and then use transloadit to encode to H264/MP4.
I did upload a file with the Screen Video 1 codec, and it worked. But, the quality of that codec is very poor. I’d prefer to encode using Screen Video 2 and then use transloadit to encode to H264/MP4.
FFMPEG certainly is falling short to handle your particular files, so I think your only option is to use an alternative codec for now. We’ve taken this on our list for future codec work so.